Originally Posted by mathman
Your absurd examples are not relevant to the real situations.


Because I magnified the situation you don't see the relevance???? I'm not sure what is hard to understand.

Originally Posted by mathman
The 338, 250 grain GK bullet is built by Sierra with a heavy jacket and hard core material so it will resist coming apart on impact with game much heavier than deer. The 270, 130 grain GK is pretty much a deer bullet.


I totally agree with this statement. But this does not make the .338 less devastating on an animal such as a whitetail. Seeing this information on the internet is simple. Go out do some research and look at pictures of whitetails shot with .338 vs .270's. It's easy for me to see which does more damage.

This is a really stupid argument. But I love the debate. I find it funny on these threads that if someone mentions the a larger caliber is better or kills faster the thread just blows up.

Most know that bigger, faster is more devastating creating larger wound channels and internal damage. Others well........