I'd choose a scope suitable for the rifle's purpose and accuracy potential. I've killed several pickup loads of jackrabbits using a run-of-the-mill rimfire rifle with a cheap 3-9x on it, and I've shot ragged hole groups at 50 yards with my 52 repro wearing a VX-3 4.5-14x40 with AO. I think AO is well worth having on an accurate .22 rifle, at least for shooting paper.