Wildpeak AT3 are great tires, I’ve ran them on several 1500 and 2500 trucks. The non LT rated tires are better for ice and snow (different compound) but overall they are great tires.
I don't have any experience with those tires, but I wonder if you had the first gen of the AT3W. Joe Bacal, professional test driver and industry consultant, posted that the AT3W compound changed for the worse just recently for the subsequent gen. He said that the AT3W was one of his favorite tires, until Falken changed the compound.
