Cant speak for the sharpmaker,
I do have a spyderco and the lansky wooden box set ( $4 clearance at academy) and a steamboat sharpener i bought from the local co-op.
All the same style.
They work*
*ive learned to use often, not let the knife get dull.
^^^This^^^
I’ve been using my Spyderco set up for YEARS.
Absolutely love it.
Like Big Dave said, don’t let your knife get to dull in the first place.