I would recommend the BPS. I have the Deer Special with the cantilever scope mount barrel and it will put 3 Hornady SST under 2 inches almost everytime at 100 yards. I think the BPS is a bargain. I also have used Remington 11-87's and 870's as well as a Mossberg 500.The BPS has some nice features such as bottom ejection and a champhered washer to keep the barrel centered on the magazine tube for better accuracy and I love a tang safety.
