Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Handguns Smith 17 or 617

My first double action S&W .22 was a 6" M17 and I thought that a K frame was too heavy for just a .22 plinker. I bought a 4" M34 that is made on the J frame and I've never missed or regretted selling off that M17.

the new ones arent as pretty as the old ones and the actions dont have as much character (for lack of a better description). the modern manufacturing techniques (MIM parts, etc.) leave a lot to be desired compared to the romance of old school smiths.

however ... the new ones have excellent triggers and excellent accuracy. they may not have the panache, but they are highly functional.

Oh-the twisted trails gun guys roam. I believe I found something a little different than I outlined above that will better meet my objectives. I purchased a Smith and Wesson Model 14-4 Target Masterpiece, and I am really impressed how sweet this piece shoots and functions. It is truly a dandy... CP.

Saw a very nice old 6" 14-3 come through LGS yesterday. The guy is National Guard and was in AZ for a pistol competition. Saw it at a pawn shop and had it shipped back here. $720 shipped no box.


Pinned bbl, patridge front sight, wide serrated trigger, target trigger. Beautiful. No wear on the barrel crown at all. Blueing exccellent.

I've got a very nice pinned barrel model 17 from the early 70's. It's large for a .22 revolver, but it's small for a .22 carbine,...and it shoots like a .22 carbine.

Been in here before, but it's a favorite that I've been shooting for fun during the bullseye off-season. 17-3 with Pachmayrs. Bought this one new a long time ago. And yeah, I love Pachmayrs.
Bob