Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Deer Hunting Sumac buck

As for me , I have not seen the pictures cause they are pulled. I don't call people phonies , but where is he to explain these phony pictures? It is no secret that S.W. Wisconsin has huge deer. He sais he lives in Grant County, Wi. and that is right next to Iowa,,, so , anyone that knows about Iowa bucks knows. As for him making things up, I must admit , I was fooled, except one time I was very suspicious of a buck he shot in Dickinson county, Michigan. This county is in Upper Michigan , and have been there many times. It is mostly sand country, nice rolling hills and beautiful land. However, it does not produce bucks like the one he said he took a picture of and said shot. A buck like that in that county is rare as hens teeth. Ask Wildhobbybobby in the campfire. He lives just down the road and he shoots 3 yr old bucks that score about 50. Roundoak said he went there , looked around a bit and shot the huge buck. That made me question the whole thing. Maybe the guy is a total phony , I don't know, but if he was posting other hunters bucks, ,, he has a lot of explaining to do. He said once some kid stole some wood and confessed and replaced the wood . Then got to know the young man at his church. Ya wonder if that was a lie too... well... I shot a spike that scores about 8? last Friday on public land . The spikes were so thin that I thought it was a doe. At least my story is real.

Well kiss my ass.I thought he was an incredibly lucky MF to have a great place to hunt,plus one in Montana.No deer for me this year in Wi.Dinks in the UP.

Some serious mental illness going on here.

Who the hell would cook up elaborate lies about shooting a deer?

Somebody needs a life.

Well, since this story broke on 11-29 he hasn't signed on to the site, at least under the roundoak user name.

That oughta tell us something.....

He's not laughing we are

I respect a man who will defend himself.

It's hard to defend 13 years of BS. Hard to believe anyone would go on a BS spree that long but it sure seems to be the case. Maybe he's related to Biden. He's been BS'ing us for 48 years and getting away with it

I commented earlier in this thread, but it still baffles me. His posts from years ago spoke specifically about his age. I’m thinking the old pictures showed an older man? Fast forward a few years and the Roundoak pictures showed a much younger man. Stumped me then, stumps me now. When I first saw the younger version in the pictures I thought maybe his son or somebody else assumed his account. I’m not on here much anymore, but I know I can’t be the only person that remembers the “old” Roundoak. There was even an old thread where some guys commented on the age discrepancy when the younger version posted a picture. Crazy stuff!

What is going on?

A guy killed a darn nice buck.





And another was spreading shït.

Sums it up.

I questioned him a few years ago about a muzzleloader buck he shot after shooting a rifle buck. He never answered and some people on here said party hunting but that doesn’t line up legally to his story he told on here.

I’m sure pics of himself are fake. My spidey senses are tingling as to who he could be, about the same time someone else was run off from here for telling stories and being a liar RO pops up.

Where’d old roundoak run off to?

Probably still hunting season.

He will reappear again under a NEW ALIAS... they all do. They just cannot stay away - like a moth to a flame.

Maybe someone contacted the Wisconsin DNR and he's in jail.

For what? Story telling?

That triggered a memory in me. I think I might have questioned that also and I think the answer back was that one of them was a Minnesota buck? I can't remember the details now.