Simmons has made really good scopes and some really bad scopes, so you might have traded for 1 on the really bad scopes.
I've been shooting a couple of old stock Philippines built Simmons Whitetail Classics in 3.5-10x40 that are as good, optically speaking, as any other <$200 scope that I've owned. I also have some 24+/- year old Simmons 1040 (2-7x) and 1053 (1.5-4.5x) that are still doing the job, despite being shot alot and being mounted on several different rifles. 1 of those 1040s has been mounted on the same Savage 24V 222/20 truck gun since 1990 and it has held up well, despite having spent most of the last 19 years in a case behind the seat of my trucks/Jeeps.
Jeff