Have you done a blind test of weighed vs. thrown charges for a pet load?
*****************************************************
Years ago, I compared "thrown" charges to my more precise method of charging a case with powder... and using the Lyman Model #55 powder dispenser, I've always found it to be very accurate, but not "perfect"... occasionally "throwing" a load of powder a tiny bit lower or higher in weight than the desired (and "set-on-the-scale") powder charge.
Perhaps this is the reason I literally "wore out" an Ohaus 505 powder scale which is now called the "RCBS 505". Ohaus stopped selling their powder scales to the public years ago and began making their scales for RCBS. When I bought the Ohaus 505, it was one of the best powder scales on the market, however the RCBS 505 is very similar to the old Ohaus 505, but not quite as nice. Thus, I purchased the RCBS 1010 powder scale, but to be honest, I liked the Ohaus 505 better because with these old eyes, I could see the markings better on the Ohaus 505 than I can on the RCBS 1010.
I am still using the original Lyman #55 powder dispenser I bought back in about 1961, but since the vast majority of my shooting is (and has been) either bench-rest loads or hunting loads, I haven't "thrown" a powder charge in a great many years.
I set the lyman to throw a powder charge 1/10th of a grain light, then I "trickle" in (between my thumb and forefinger) the scale's powder pan the last 1/10th of a grain until the powder scale indicator moves up to "0" on the RCBS 1010 powder scale.
Thus, I weight each and every powder charge I use, but frankly, the Lyman #55 powder dispenser "throws" extremely reliable and equal powder charges as long as the hopper is reasonably full.
I never allow the Lyman powder container to get below half-full when dispensing powder. Yes, I admit that I'm just "
super picky"... but absolute "accuracy" is always my ultimate goal and I never do any reloading if I'm in a "hurry".
To be perfectly honest, a bullet fired using a Lyman#55 "thrown" powder charge would very likely be as accurate as my more "perfect" powder charges because the Lyman's charges are almost always within 1/100th of a grain or less of what the dispenser is set to throw. However, my powder charges are
EXACTLY the weight of powder I want in the cartridge case.
Perhaps it wouldn't make the least bit of difference...
except to me.
Incidentally, the muzzle velocities I have given in other posts are
chronographed muzzle velocities. If I'm guessing at a velocity, I'll say "estimated muzzle velocity"... or "about xxxx fps" which indicates it is not a chronographed velocity.
Strength & Honor...
Ron T.