Based on what you're looking for, I feel like I'm in the same search. Here's what I've narrowed it down to:
Leupold VX-6, 2-12x42 CDS turrets with zero lock and firedot windplex reticle or
NF 2.5-10x42 with turrets and zero lock and either the mil-dot or Velocity 600 reticle
Eye relief is 3.8 vs 3.5 if I remember correctly. Leupold makes the same scope in a 3-18x44 for basically the same weight and size as the 12x but I can't see needing an 18x on a hunting rifle.
So those are the two scopes that have me up at night wondering which is best.
