You’re all wrong. They shouldn’t be accepting any returns on ammo regardless of the circumstances. To do so is a safety risk to others. As an example, someone could have reloaded them using unique which would, of course, wreck anyone’s firearm and endanger the life and limb of the shooter. PB, you owe it to your fellow shooters to keep it.
In case you are wondering, I had a similar occurrence happen with Nosler. I ordered 500 rounds of their custom loaded 222 ammo. What I got was 222 Magnum. I notified them of the error and offered to ship it back. They said keep it for the above reason and promptly sent me what I ordered.
But you gave them the option and your conscience was clear.
