Lots of folks here with common sense.
A few with pontification.
Probably typical.
And I used to be the one to carry whats in the gun because I thought I'd never see the day.
Today I rarely set foot without a full box of ammo. And consider that could not get me to a dead animal just depending... ONE bad shot and a rodeo and shooting circus can ensue.
Jab the guy when he is down and has lost an elk, doing the very best he personally could/knew how to. He made a few decisions, and they may not have been the best, but its his deal, not ours. And he is still around and not in a hospital.
BTW I don't practice either... FWIW. But I can certianly hit a grapefruit, and alot further than 50 yards...with many weapons.