You are very likely to end up with a great rifle irrespective of which one you buy. Functionally you can expect them to be near equals. Given that, here's the way I would proceed. I would ask myself a few questions and let the answers to those questions guide me.
Where is the gun made?
Does the company have a reputation for excellent customer service?
Does the rifle have a friendly scope mounting system?
Which one has the preferred or most robust bolt/feed/extraction?
