Update on this. I broke down several weeks ago, bit the bullet and threw a lot of money at the following:
Green
Blue
Carbon
Yellow (elevated heel shoes)
I've rotated them in/out of different shoes and have found that the shoe they are in makes as much of a difference as the insole and shape of your foot. Blue (and Carbon) seems to be the closest to the shape of my foot/arch. After trying them out I didn't think I would use the Green but it ends up it feels better than the Blue in one pair of shoes. The Yellow works well in a pair of work/riding boots with a slight heel. Carbon is really nice in tennis shoes and better overall than my custom orthodics.
