I've used the Kuiu for four- five years, still on my original set.
I've waded 14 inches of river water, blundered into bog sinks, hiked through over 2 feet of snow, and through popcorn-fart dry forest.
Pros: Velcro is holding as firm as ever - my Kenetrek set lasted one season that I recall, they didn't keep me as dry either.
No rips, and I should have shredded them - they've been snagged on a dead fall more than once.
Haven't leaked yet, the boots wet through before the gaiter could let any water in.
IMHO - they are easy to adjust for your boot size, and height, the stirrup strap has not torn, or cut, and still looks pretty solid.
The upper leg cinch is easy to adjust, and seals tight.
Cons: they can be hot to wear in the early Fall, they don't let moisture out either.
+1
I’ve used OR Crocs and Kuiu gaiters extensively, and prefer the Kuiu’s for the reasons mentioned above. The snap on the toe is an upgrade over the OR’s velcro tab.
