I've looked into the PCP side of the house, but not interested. Too much logistics for my taste.

I liked the simplicity of my old Sheridan 5mm, and if I getting another air rifle I want it to be simple also. But one stroke of the barrel beats 8-10 pumps with the Sheridan, so I'm looking for something break-barrel, or underlever. I like the looks of the Diana 460, but the regular break barrel looks easier to load, especially with cold hands.

RWS 3500 doesn't look bad to me either. More of a classic look, with a nice comb for optics.