Big gaiter fan. I wear them all hunting season. They can get warm - but I take them if they do. In general, I rarely take them off. If you see me in hunting season without gaiters, its because i forgot them........Kennetrek for me.
Whatever you chose, DO NOT BUY ANY WITH ANY TYPE OF CLOTH on the band under the boot. I had a pair of Cabelas gaiter early on and the strap under the boot was some kind material that absorbed water - which caused snow to stick to it. It felt like walking around with a softball under you foot.
I have a pair of Kuiu that only cover about 4-5-6 inches. They work great for early season and general hiking. Keeps stick, leaves, dirt out of my hiking shoes/boots.
