Ah, yes. A test done by someone unknown using testing methods that aren't described and, guess what ? Leupold comes out on the bottom. And another expert telling us that light transmition numbers mean nothing.
I believe guys like Barsness who aren't impressed with tiny differences based on his experiences in the field. And we get to know just how he tested.
Then there is JJHack who says they all work, right down to the 32mm sizes. The biggest factor is being able to see the reticle. You don't need to see much of the target, but you do need to see the reticle. That after many years of hunting and killing all sorts of game at night.
Then there is my own expereince at night. According to this test, I didn't see that herd of elk, in the dark at 125 yds. and couldn't tell that one was a spike. That's because I was only using a 6X42 Leupold M8. E