I know the "which caliber" topic has been beat to death, but would appreciate some opinions opinions on which makes the most sense for my 1st guided elk hunt this Fall. Guide says shots typically from 150-400 yds. I personally want to get as close as possible but know it's not always possible.
Win 70 in 270 Wby w/ 2.5x8 glass. Have hunted with it for years and trust it, but I'm on the fence if it's a bit light for Elk and if its enough magnification?
Rem 700 Mountain Rifle in 375 H&H 1.75-6 glass. New to the stable and haven't hunted with it yet, but it shoots well and is lighter and more handy than the Bee. Being a Winchester man I realize the bolt handle may fall off during an Elk charge, but I'm willing to take the risk...
I'd like to use the 375 (since I bought it for possible heavy stuff) but the potential for a long range shot is making me think twice.
What do you think?
............Although both are do-able, I`d go with your 270 Bee as well. A 270 Wby certainly isn`t under-gunned for any elk. And your 2.5x8 glass is about right on the money too, especially if as you say, your guide says shots are typically 150-400 yards. Magnified to 8x, that scope would be good imo for elk out about 600-700 yards if necessary.
For a big moose or dangerous bear hunt at closer ranges maybe within less open country, then I`d be more inclined to opt and use a 375.
