Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Hunter's Campfire Navy Seal Commander on trial

Not a commander, he is an enlisted Master Chief, been following this story for a while now and have mixed feelings on it.

Interesting.

in a time of war one must do what is necessary.

given the makeup of the jury box, i'd hope he'll walk.

it's just that justice must be done, and hopefully the right jury has been picked.

We recruit these guys train them and send them in harm’s way. Then we prosecute them if they don’t play nice. They are supposed to seek out, and kill our enemies.

I saw a lengthy report on this on the new last night. Said the guy did 8 tours.
They said he had a captured teen age ISIS fighter, and killed him with a knife.
Said that, from his sniper's hideout, he shot a teen age girl, and an old man.

So hard to call justice on this one, from the safety of the states. Old men, and teen age girls are used by Muslims to plant bombs and kill Americans.
Stabbed a teen age captive? Is there video? Did the kid grab a knife and try to kill the SEAL? Are there eye witnesses?

I am sure that bad things happen in combat zones but, so hard to put judgement on a case like this.

There's nothing to try. He deserves another medal and try the ones that accused him instead.

He found enemy, killed enemy, pretty much all I need to know. The rest is political masturbation we just don't need.

Gve him a medal a free house, and an apology.

+100

imop I think they need to stop this bs . a man that made his mind up to fight &kill on our behalf should be fugg with ! ! ! the enemy has no rules our men should not have any

left out not beer mistake

I haven't followed it too closely but from what I've seen I'd say the guy is fugged.

The see-saw with his prosecution for this is what is sickening.

Back and forth, cleared then prosecuted.

Someone's got an axe to grind.

Guess I am a little different. Having served 22 years, I see his actions as an embarrassment to all service members. His defense is calling his Seal team mutinous. So he was the good guy and the rest of the team the bad guys???????

If he walks, it will be a slap in the face of all service members that chose to do the right thing day in and day out.

My thoughts also

An article about the alleged crimes.
The controversial war crimes trial of Navy SEAL Edward "Eddie" Gallagher is set to begin Monday after months of disputes between defense lawyers and military prosecutors that have reverberated all the way up to the White House.


Special Operations Chief Gallagher, 39, heads to a court-martial after pleading not guilty to premeditated murder and aggravated assault charges stemming from the alleged killing of a wounded ISIS terrorist and alleged instances of him intentionally firing sniper rounds at civilians in Iraq.


Jury selection begins Monday -- just weeks after a judge booted the military’s lead prosecutor from the case over unsanctioned tracking of the defense team's emails. As part of a remedy, the judge is letting Gallagher’s legal team reject two additional potential jurors without cause during the selection process, according to the Associated Press.

"Over the course of the trial we will expose the false narrative spread by these accusers for what it is… a smear campaign full of lies," read a post put up late last night on a Facebook page connected to his family. "Our team will show that the truth is not only our client’s best defense, but most importantly, that the truth proves SOC Gallagher’s innocence."

Navy Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher leaves a military courtroom on Naval Base San Diego with his wife, Andrea Gallagher in San Diego.
Navy Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher leaves a military courtroom on Naval Base San Diego with his wife, Andrea Gallagher in San Diego. (AP)

The months leading up to Monday's proceedings have been marked with disputes between defense lawyers and military prosecutors over the conditions of Gallagher’s pre-trial treatment. At one point, even President Trump got involved and tweeted Gallagher would be moved to “less restrictive confinement while he awaits his day in court.”

JUDGE REMOVES PROSECUTOR ACCUSED OF MISCONDUCT IN EDDIE GALLAGHER CASE

Gallagher was undergoing a medical screening at Camp Pendleton and was in the process of transitioning to a non-combat advisory role for the Navy SEALs when he was taken into custody in September 2018, his brother Sean said. Gallagher had planned to retire in the spring.

Throughout his 19 years of service, Gallagher earned the Bronze Star with V for Valor twice, a Meritorious Unit commendation and a trio of Navy and Marine Corps Achievement medals, among other recognitions and decorations.

He fought in Iraq and Afghanistan several times, reaching the status of what Sean Gallagher described as a “modern-day war hero.”

Throughout his 19 years of service, Gallagher earned the Bronze Star with V for Valor twice, a Meritorious Unit commendation, and a trio of Navy and Marine Corps Achievement medals, among other recognitions and decorations.
Throughout his 19 years of service, Gallagher earned the Bronze Star with V for Valor twice, a Meritorious Unit commendation, and a trio of Navy and Marine Corps Achievement medals, among other recognitions and decorations. (Courtesy Sean Gallagher)
GALLAGHER’S WIFE SAYS SHE, CHILDREN ‘HAD A GOOD, LONG CRY’ AFTER HUSBAND’S PRE-TRIAL RELEASE

It was during Gallagher’s final combat deployment, in 2017, that he's alleged to have committed war crimes. The Naval Criminal Investigative Service launched an investigation into Gallagher in April 2018.

Investigators allege that, while a teen ISIS fighter was receiving medical treatment from SEAL medics, Gallagher walked up and stabbed him in his neck and side with a knife, killing the terrorist. Then, they say, he posed for photographs with the fighter’s body, holding his head in one hand and his blade in the other.

Those allegations have been called into question, however, by top Iraqi military officials. Gallagher’s legal team, the Associated Press reported, also plans to call in fellow SEALS during the trial to testify about what happened during that pivotal 2017 deployment.

Sean Gallagher, right, says he believes his brother has been falsely accused and is calling on President Trump for help. “We are really thankful that this time in history we have a president that we are hoping can come to our assistance that would look at the grievous nature of his treatment of the abuse of power by NCIS and prosecutors and come to our aid," he said in a past interview with 'Fox & Friends'.
Sean Gallagher, right, says he believes his brother has been falsely accused and is calling on President Trump for help. “We are really thankful that this time in history we have a president that we are hoping can come to our assistance that would look at the grievous nature of his treatment of the abuse of power by NCIS and prosecutors and come to our aid," he said in a past interview with 'Fox & Friends'. (Courtesy Sean Gallagher)
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Multiple people close to Gallagher have described him as being hard on his men. Last year, Sean Gallagher suggested his brother may be in his current legal predicament due to a "few malcontents of guys" alongside him overseas "that didn’t like being reprimanded for not wanting to engage in combat.”

“My brother has been eager for a long, long time now to clear his name and actually have witnesses come and testify on his behalf,” he previously told "Fox & Friends."

It seems like a bit of a stretch to bridge the gap between not liking your boss and accusing him of three murders.

Problem is, there are a bunch of obviously scapegoated guys in the brig for guys doing the right thing and protecting their men and persecuted by Zeros anti military jag.

I do wonder what a jury would think is 'more probable' regarding Gallagher and his team members

That he was one good apple in barrel of bad ones, or one bad apple in a barrel of good ones?