Although I haven't done a lot, I've done some research on the net and haven't found anyone badmouthing Mcwhorter or his rifles. In and of itself that speaks volumes. There aren't any world class gunsmiths where I live. I don't wish to wait a couple of years, or even one to receive a rifle. I am looking at Ed Brown, Dakota, Mcmillan, Borden, and of course Mr. Mcwhorter's work. It looks to me that the alignment issues are using Borden's actions in Mcmillan stocks. This is exactly the action and stock I'd purchase. I have the same reservations that Popapi has. Fortunately I don't have to make a decison right this moment.
Just wanted to make something clear here--I offer two styles of bolt handles--I still offer the Rem 700 handle for those that have stocks with the Rem bolt Handle cutout already done. McMillan is offering the Rem 700 inletting for my actions with the straight bolt handle cutout as well.
I for one could stand to see more McWhorter rifle pictures from owners with targets. Lee
This is a picture of a target that required a one shot group from my McWhorter at just under 400 yards. It's takes a while to draw an Arizona Unit 1 antelope tag,I'm glad that I took the McWhorter rifle.
only you can decide this question some guys are happy with a $700.00 remington some a $1500.00 semi custom and others would say that both of those people are nuts to spend that on a gun.If it makes you happy and you can afford it then it was worth it. I will say that borden rifles is now offering their basic model rifle with their action which mcwhorters uses alot at $2995.00 and i think that is alot of gun for the money when comparing other top builders.
As soon as I sell my home, I will retire, and be Colorado bound. My retirement present will be one of these high end (for me) McWhorter/Borden/Dakota/Ed Brown rifles. Wish Mr. Borden would post pics of his current rifles for sale on his website also...
Tim just finished my new 7mm wsm. Stiller action, McMillan BDL stock, #5 Hart. After brake in, this is the first group I shot. 66.5grs of Supreme 780 under 168 Berger VLD's. Getting 3060fps out of them too.
I have no experience with the rifles you mentioned EXCEPT Ed Brown and Jim Borden. As I researched, it was pretty clear that the fit/workmanship of Borden's was significantly better than Brown. As far as performance, my Borden 300 wsm came with a test target of .22 (3 shot group) My results have been the same...my worst group has been .63 with factory stuff. I found jim to be helpful and quick to return a call/email.(and patient with a newbie to the custom world)
Since my purchase I understand that the wait times are down with the addition of some more equipment. (they were a little long at the time of my purchase a couple of years ago)
I handled a few Browns, talked to Ed himself. (my conversations with him were not real helpful) I did not actually fire one...but then again I didn't have to. PM if you need any more info. My next one will be a Borden!
Greg
Kiss your girlfriend where it smells.......take her to Jersey!