Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Deer Hunting Penetration vs. Frag

nothing quite so ridiculous as a one man pi--ing contest

Well, I was enjoying the earlier part of this thread !

Paul.

Maybe you just lay down for bullies and liars - I don't.


Mule Deer's continued silence speaks volumes. He lied.

And on, and on,and on,and on---------------------.I don't think anyone gives a chit

Mule Deer is no bully. Quite the opposite.

Someone that goes to such obsessive lengths to "prove" they are "right", falls into the same same category of bullies, liars and other blowhards.

But ok, I will bite and play..... keeping in the SAAMI ratings, with the proper velocity and trajectory I can push 6.5 feet. How healthy is your prostate? Don't bother answering, the line is shut down now as it doesn't matter.

Yep, I too, like JB just fine.

Paul.

Coyote Hunter. I thought that you made some good points, more then held your own and proved your point about the edits. Time to let it rest though.

Nothing wrong with my prostate � it came out a couple months ago. Glad yours is healthy now, but time will take care of that.

How about something more fun and interesting than a peeing contest? Let�s go shoot clay pigeons at 600 yards, $100 to the winner.

I'd be willing to shoot at them.

You don't want Ingwe to show up though, he will get all your money.

Years of shooting incredibly small deer have made him a crack shot.

That there is down right funny JM !!

Sure, but you have to dress and cook them. Like mine med rare with pearl onions and mushrooms.

On deer you can have both. Shoot a decent-weight-for-caliber Accubond and get penetration AND fragmentation!

By the way... your question ties directly into something I called "way overpenetrating". This generated some real amusement around here. In essence, most deer are relatively small and fragile animals. Something like, oh let's just pick something at random here.... say, the TSX is putting too much of it's efforts into heating up the ground behind the deer for my tastes- considering that, as JB and others already said so well, it's not like modern hunting bullets UNDERPENETRATE on deer. And a quicker kill- which many luminaries, to include JB and JJHack, have reported with bullets that frag some- ain't not a good thing.

Until I see a problem, personally a mid-premie like the NAB or NPT is about all the harder I want a deer bullet to be. Heck, they've worked great on elk for me too so.....

Wacky thread. Two people I consider to be bastions of reasonable discourse around here kinda got under each other's skin and got nas-tay. Hope it got patched up.

I was hoping this was dead and buried.