When I have weight on my back and a long hike ahead, "value" is the last thing going through my mind.
Packs are very subjective and you learn very quickly what is good for you.
Well said, I already have "value" packs, a gearskin made from a 10th SF Lowe, and an ALICE, and I don't want an 8# pack unless someone gave it to me, just like I don't want anymore eight or nine pound sporter rifles with crap for triggers and stocks. I also want a pack that can carry 50-65# for long hikes with a packraft, a Longhunter would be overkill for that. The McHale might not be as good of a meat-hauler as the ILBE or a Longhunter, but it would be a far better general purpose pack, IMO. Pounds equal pain, I'm looking at neck surgery in the future, and a heavy ALICE is partly responsible, along with 200 jumps and a SERE school azz-whipping.