For me, the choice was easy. The Smith.
It has the positives of safety, durability, size and weight.

Caliber is just fine. And it was designed from the start with a true case supporting chamber as all .40's should have.

Did not hurt that it is a NIB specimen, original owner, non PD issue piece with box and additional aftermarket grip.

It will get a range workout soon. Doubt it kicks the G26/G19 to the curb for carry, but I bet the results will impress.