I have been shooting my Ruger No.1S in 45-70 since 1993. Yes the cost was about twice as much as a good bolt gun. Why did I buy it? It just appeals to me. I can't really say why. I always admired this rifle and also have a strong interest in the 45-70 Gov. So to me that rifle and caliber are just about perfect. I'm not saying it is the best choice for every body but for me it has always been a very enjoyable set up. Some guns(and calibers) just appeal to certain shooters. Why do some shooters still shoot lever guns with iron sights? Why do people still shoot single action Colt revolvers? Why not just get a Glock 17? As for hunting, I hunt with my No.1 every other year rotating back and forth between that rifle and my 30-06. As far as cost goes I do not know. You would have to talk to the manufacturers. We all have that certain type of firearm that seems to call out to us. That's part of the fun.