In the same vein as prm, here are a couple of pics of various puffy and similar purpose jackets.

Kuiu 240 Peleton (L), Sitka Kelvin Lite (R)

[Linked Image]

Sitka Core Heavyweight (L), Patagonia R1 hoody (M), Kuiu 240 Peleton (L)

[Linked Image]

Sitka Traverse Cold Weather hoody (L), Sitka Kelvin Lite hoody (R)

[Linked Image]

All 4 together

[Linked Image]

Interestingly, the most windproof is the Kuiu 240 Peleton. It didn't occur to me to wear it as a mid layer until prm posted. It is about the same weight as the R1 and Core Heavyweight. I also did the "light test" to the KLH. You can't see specific light 'holes/beams' through the material but you can see the light illuminating the material from the opposite side of the light, especially as the stitching. It still breathes fairly well - you can blow air through it (my empirical windproof test).

The Sitka Traverse Cold weather hoody isn't a puffy but is deathly quiet, warm, and breathes. I don't think its as warm as the KLH but the exterior is quiet. I ended up with it kind of by accident and decided to keep it. Its worth a consideration as well.


Adversity doesn't build character, it reveals it.