Hudge.
FWIW, Here's how I solved the on road/off road tires.

Have had 4WDs for last 25 yrs.
Been thru many all terrain tires, Was never satisfied with any of them.
Tried mud tires but got lots of road noise and poor mileage.

Last truck I ordered with highway tires.
Was easy to find a set of take-off steel rims for my truck.
(seems most would replace these steel rims with aluminum alloys - was very inexpensive)
Put a set of full out mud tires on the 2nd set of rims.
1" space between lugs with sidewall lugs also.

9 months out of the year I use the highway tires.
Put the mud tires on for hunting season and winter snow.

Am still amazed how much better the highway tires drive/handle on pavement.
Mud tires work well in mud and snow!


Ray