Since you said the project is something to remember the guy by why not ask him what his favorite cartridge is and why? That might get you a rifle that will have several "layers" of qualities to remember him by.
Now that is some pretty good advice there!!! Thank you!
I've read ALL of this thread so far. These quotes are on P 4.
I've squelched out all the 'static' and bs from bs (per normal).
1. I'd agree with your wishes to do a rifle to remember someone -- whatever that'd be.
2. If you want a 8X57 by all means get one, sincerely. I have a 300 WM, because I want one.
3. For myself there is NO dilema; the 30-06 (30 cal) has SO MANY options that the 8 mauser can't compete.
You only have to please yourself. Good Luck
Jerry
