Personally, If I was unaccustomed to warm weather tarp or floorless, I would go with a more traditional tent for late fall.
Archery season here is not in late Fall, it's in early Fall.
Big difference. If you'd ever hunted here during Fall, you'd know that.
I was going to say something but you got it...
On topic, it depends as I use both.
I prefer floorless tipi tents...walk in, take of the boots etc inside and don't worry about tracking in mud, light the stove, and sleep is good.
