Elk, I think the term "good" is purely subjective.
Bit like trying to judge ice skating / ice dancing at the Olympics !!
To the OP - Mathman, how about you start a new thread.
We can't all afford to keep "top shelf" in our cabinets, so why not start a thread on "If you had to choose one Scotch / Bourbon / Rye to drink everyday, what would it be & why".
Paul.
