Your post has me a bit confused.
If smoke and peat are what you want then Laphroaig, Lagavulin and Ardbeg are tops. They can be a bit dominating if you're not into what they deliver so much of.
For an excellent whisky where smoke and peat are present but not dominating try Highland Park, particularly the 18 or for less money the 12. Their more recent 15 year old release is good but doesn't quite fit right with the 12 and 18.
