There's a gun shop up here in Minnesota that makes a real nice living fixing Remington semi-automatics-they make pumps out of them! Personally, I'd go with the Browning, but that doesn't answer your question.
The Winny's better looking, but the Remington is probably a bit more accurate, at least in the several I've had experience with. The Remington is called the Minnesota Machine Gun up here by the many who either love it or hate it. Put on a set of see through rings and the cheapest 4x scope you can find, and you'll fit right in. If you really want to make the grade, hammer one of those little dime sized compasses into the stock and get a 20 round magazine for it!
