Originally Posted by Barak
Originally Posted by RupertBear
Originally Posted by Barak

I'll say further that he did the right thing.


I can't buy that. He is/was a soldier, sworn to obey the lawful orders of his superiors. Those lawful orders included regulations that prohibited the copying and dissemination of classified information. At the very least, he disobeyed orders.

Yes, he disobeyed orders. Yes, he broke his oath. Yes, he committed treason. Still, he did the right thing.

The only other conclusion available would be to support the N�rnberg Defense.


Where you and I disagree is that you consider his orders against general dissemination of classified information unlawful; I don't.