I wish the Judge worked, but it doesn't. As such, I wish that Smith would come out with a 3" chambered model. The Judge chambered in 3" with a five shot cylinder and 3" barrel is very handy. You combine that with Smith's Scandium frame and you would have something. 45 ACP capability is nice but I'd rather have the 3" .410 if I could trade. The Judge seems heavier but is more compact due to its slimmer profile, being five-shot.
