Originally Posted by Old_Man
Originally Posted by PaulBarnard
Next time you get a chance fill two 1 gallon milk jugs up with water. Shoot one with a 17 HMR at 100 yards and one with a 40 gr JSP 22 magnum at 100 yards. See if that influences your thoughts about penetration, disruption and power.



Groundhogs ain't milk jugs, and I perfer to judge it by the groundhogs reaction to it, A 30.06 and a 22/250 have similar milkjug explosions at 200 yds,(yes Sir I have tried it before), but at that range the deer knows the difference, too. I'll stay with my previous observation.


+1 on Rock chucks to around 15# and Jack Rabbits the 17HMR is excellent. Body shots seriously shock them. Often just a tail twitch and DRT. Shot a chuck last summer at 286 yards on a perfect no wind evening. Anything 200 and under is in serious trouble.


A true sportsman counts his achievements in proportion to the effort involved and fairness of the sport. - S. Pope