That is a sad thing to hear of a stolen 57. I have a 6" 57 and if I had to sell my guns, it'd be one the very last I'd let go of.
I shoot 210gr Nosler JHP's over H110 for hunting loads. I've messed with some laser cast and h110 for range loads. I haven't quite settled on what I want to use for general plinking/practice loads yet.
