Ive owned both. I’d be more concerned with layout and the transom. Lunds are riveted and do just fine on the great lakes. Living in the PNW, I had an Alumaweld and fished the open ocean quite a bit. Fishing seasons started to get cut short and my Alumaweld was a pig for anything but trolling. So I sold it as my needs changed. Now I own a Lund and its been great for lakes and big slow rivers like the Columbia and Snake. Its a lot easier to control using a bow mount.