I have been disappointed in the penetration of the heavier jacketed bullets out of a 357. My 2 cents says that a hard cast 158-160 gr SWC bullet, is far more reliable. This style of bullet used to often be referred to a "keith style" as old Elmer used to preach this as gospel. I agree.
Trialed some heavier cast bullets and had trouble with accuracy and was not happy with velocities. I have never used any of the fully jacketed (military style) bullets for hunting, but I do like some of the copper washed cast bullets.
My experience has been with whitetails, 1 bear, and several Florida hogs. A 4" S&W mod 19 is my weapon of choice for hogs. Most of this shooting is close to very close range.
In reality, a good 44 Special load will provide performance that is superior to a 357, in every way.
