Originally Posted by Mannlicher
Without a lot of range time using those heavy .357 loads, she, or anyone else, is going to have difficulty getting off a second aimed shot. Not saying it can be done, but doing takes a lot of practice.

For sure.

Phil Shoemaker, while guiding a fishing party, reportedly killed a big bear with his 9mm. IIRC, he used heavy for caliber, hard cast bullets.

But, Phil is an experienced guide, knows where to hit a bear, is a cool operator under pressure and obviously knows how to shoot.

You just don't find that combo in many individuals.

For the average gringo armed with a pistol, I'd give the advantage to the bear. I think odds makers in Vagus would probably back that..

DF