I've always regarded the 270 Win a scaled-down, light-recoiling 300 mag. Similar trajectories and killing power.
Before he died, I corresponded a bit with George Hoffman, Professional African Hunter, and the developer of the 416 Hoffman (which eventually became the 416 Rem Mag). His elk rifle was the 270 Win. All his nearly 50 elk were taken with the cartridge he told me.
Daughter #1 will be using a new-to-her .270 for elk this year. 150g ABLR @ 2910fps. Fairly mild recoil, 2000fps and 1500fpe to 740 yards. Given her comfort range of 400 yards I think it will be adequate. Hope she gets an opportunity to prove as much.
