As you note, there are a bazillion holster makers out there. Very few of them make a really crappy holster. Most of them make a pretty decent holster at a minimum. Holster preference is so personal that it's very difficult to get better advice from a stranger on the internet, than by figuring things out for yourself, hence the reason so many folks have so many extra holsters laying around. For example, you haven't stated if you intend to carry appendix IWB, three thirty IWB, or OWB. How is someone else supposed to figure that out for you?
