When comparing medium frame .357's, specifically S&W, Ruger, and Colt...No matter what, you're going to end up with a fantastic revolver. It comes down to the little things that do it for you. Look, feel, sights, trigger...etc. Everyone has a revolver that just does it for them...just make sure you buy the one that does it for you. Or you'll have to go back at a later date and buy the one that does it for you. Might as well 100% satisfy the heart the first time; its cheaper that way.