There's no doubt I'd prefer a semi; don't have an XDS, but I do have a G26 & G27 & they are simply too heavy (20moz empty) to match the ease of carrying the revolver......the size is not the main issue, for me, but the weight is.

How much does the XDS weigh, loaded up?

Are you realistically carrying it in your front pants/shorts pocket?

Pic of the gun in a front pants pocket?

MM