He wasn't shy about pimping things that literally have not been out for a full year yet (Athlon)... how could they possibly be vetted?
I guess he did give himself an out by kiboshing the notion that mechanical precision isn't a big factor... "use the reticle!"... but that in itself makes me suspicious of his cred. Is he known as a highly skilled LR shooter?
Ridiculous to write off SFP scopes, too.
Thinly-disguised mashup of google-fu is my opinion.