�Render unto Caesar the things which are Caesar�s, and unto God the things that are God�s�

Because the First Amendment of the Constitution protects our right to speak, and is part of our secular law, such speech is a manifestation of a thing belonging to Man (Caesar). This same First Amendment also protects the individual right to speak of Holy things, such as Scripture and our relationships with God. It applies to all religions, including atheism. To ban any free speech, on either side of the issue, would defeat God's desideratum governing free will.

Such a ban based on the police power of the state would also constitute an establishment of religion. For example, in one National Forest Native Americans are proposing restricting the year round small and non-game hunting season so they can conduct religious ceremonies free from the sound of occasional gun fire. To promulgate a law denying a legitimate recreational activity on public land for the purpose of supporting a specific religion would violate the First Amendment restriction against governmental establishment of religion. Same with the free exercise of religious speech, as in the case of the Westboro Baptist Church, such offensive speech may violate various sectarian religious beliefs, and common decency, but it can not be interfered with using the power of the state.

As for God, He seems to prefer that each of us decide for ourselves on matters of faith. Anyone forced by the power of the state, through theocratic or secular rule, to obey a certain religious practice, is not redeemed in God's eyes. That is why God does not merely raise His hand and instantly illuminate everyone as to His existence and purpose. It is for us to decide to believe and follow. God would abhor beating our neighbor into submission to any religion, such would condemn both to His displeasure.

God also has designed conflict into every physical, moral and spiritual question, through the agency of opposing beliefs struggling with one another. Consider this: God is the Creator of the universe, He is fully capable of enforcing His law whenever He chooses. If homosexuality, and all the mortal sins are against His law, offending His dignity, He has deliberately deferred passing judgment. Therefore, these things serve His purpose with Mankind, which brings us back to the experience, the debate, and the resolution in each individual heart. Thus, we render to God that which is God's. Meaning we voluntarily give to him our heart, allegiance and faith, in acknowledgment of our dependence and obligation to Him.

These questions will never be resolved in this world. It is up to each of us to practice according to our choices, hoping that what we do is pleasing to Him and purifying for us.