Keep the cod and yelloweye. Give away the halibut. The most important issue,with fish, Imo is how was the fish treated after it hit the boat. Call me a snob but I won't take fish from anyone without knowing how it was treated.
ROFL, I hear you, sir! We used to kill and bleed our fish right out of the water. I still gave away or traded most of the halibut because we always had plenty.