Keep the cod and yelloweye. Give away the halibut. The most important issue,with fish, Imo is how was the fish treated after it hit the boat. Call me a snob but I won't take fish from anyone without knowing how it was treated.
Completely agree.
My grandfather who was born in 1905 and lived on the coast in Maine, had a rule about fish that he lived by his whole life. It had to be "caught on the incoming tide". Of course that made more sense when he was young and guys still fished off of sailboats and rowboats, but it got the point across that he liked his fish FRESH.
