I don't know handguns a bit EE, but my pre-27 N frame and first gen Trooper as fine as frog hair too me, if anything out there is more fitting, I don't have the talent to recognize it.
I'd feel well protected by either of yours. The two 357's currently in my stable are my wife's Magnum Carry above (which I didn't even rate) and my 28 pictured earlier, which is simply a no-frills version of your gun.
