I don't know handguns a bit EE, but my pre-27 N frame and first gen Trooper as fine as frog hair too me, if anything out there is more fitting, I don't have the talent to recognize it.
I'd feel well protected by either of yours. The two 357's currently in my stable are my wife's Magnum Carry above (which I didn't even rate) and my 28 pictured earlier, which is simply a no-frills version of your gun.
Thanks EE, bet yours are good runners too, I have to say the old Trooper on ones side with four speed loaders in a Carhartt left side pocket doesn't feel all that bad as far as SD/CCW goes, I carried that 8-3/8ths barreled pre-27 a few times in the woods this year, nothing got close enough for me to try it out on, that Bianchi leather holster TheKid gave me for it soaked up no less than a dozen coats of jojoba oil all last year, it's a fine, fine holster for that old revolver.
