As a reminder, the OP was asking about compact 22 semi-autos. I am surprised some tard hasn't mentioned a Creedmore yet.
Give'em time...
I think the statement, "the one she likes" is the way to go.
And, renting different guns at a range with rounds fired makes good sense.
If they're not bought in, have confidence in and really like the gun, you've not accomplished much.
DF